The biggest disadvantages of plaster are cost, installation time, and repair difficulty. It needs skilled labor and multiple coats with drying time between layers, so it takes longer and costs more than drywall.
Other drawbacks include:
- Cracking over time, especially in homes with settling
- Harder, messier repairs compared to patching drywall
- Fewer skilled plasterers in many areas
- A heavier material that adds weight to walls and ceilings
- Long cure times before you can prime and paint
Plaster still offers real benefits, including durability and sound control, so these drawbacks matter most on tight budgets or fast timelines. For restoration or high-end projects, many homeowners find the trade-offs worthwhile. A plasterer can tell you if repairing existing walls makes more sense than replacing them.